Skip to main content

If You're Not a Sloth, You're a Glutton. And Vice Versa.

Okay, I'll admit (don't lose respect for me), I've stopped reading Gary Taubes's "Good Calories, Bad Calories".  While it was a very impressive body of work, it was also very dense, hard to sift through, and just too darn scientific and data-based.  That stuff is important to me, but I already accept the premise...I kept waiting for Taubes to give advice.  And I waited...and waited...

However, this girl's got a Plan B.  I picked up Taubes's "Why We Get Fat and What To Do About It",  a recently-published text that I suspect he put out in response to readers like myself who just wanted a super-duper condensed version of GCBC and more tips and advice.

Thirty pages in, my expectation is met so far.  Taubes has summarized rather handily the tomes of research that exist regarding obesity, etc...both positive and negative outcomes.  Early on, it's clear that science, public health, government have made mistakes...ones they seem reluctant to fix.

Anyway, there are several older studies that indicate obesity was once a "disease of malnutrition" instead of overnutrition (29).  Taubes then goes to explain that most doctors, parents, nutritionists, dietitians, consumers, etc. have believed in the calories in-calories out process (that we gain weight when we consume more cals than we burn).  Thus, if one was obese, it was either because s/he was inactive or was an overeater (either s/he was a sloth (lazy) or a glutton).  However, Taubes highlights study after study that indicates obesity had nothing to do with activity. After all, according to the conventional knowledge, poverty-level sharecroppers in 1950's South Carolina should have been thin (because they couldn't afford much food and worked physically demanding jobs)...but they weren't (26).  An unusual number of those folks (and many others) were overweight.

Taubes suggests that we forget about labels (sloth or glutton?) and judgments (lazy or a pig?) and instead, consider that something is wrong with our food supply.

It doesn't seem like a wholly revolutionary idea, but essentially: stop worrying about how much we eat, and worry more about what we eat.

And that is what I am in the middle of trying to figure out.  What should I eat?  Who's right?  The USDA (Meat & Beans are just a sliver on the current food pyramid)?  Michael Pollan (Eat more.  Mostly plants.)?  Gary Taubes/Dr. Atkins/Arthur Agatston (Meat is good.  Stay away from high-carb...even if it's a fruit or vegetable)?

The answers are out there.  They have to be.

Comments

  1. The only thing I can tell you is this. I have lost 24 pounds, not by dieting, but by eating more whole grains, more fresh or frozen fruits and veggies less meat, cheese and dairy.

    The Mediterranean Pyramid is a better starting point than the USDA's pyramid. The only thing I've totally omitted from my menu is anything that comes in a can.

    ReplyDelete
  2. okay, You've convinced me. I've got to read this book!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Go Placidly

My food truck business started back up this past weekend, and from here until November, the weeks will be packed.  Sandwich-slinging Thursday-Saturday and bartending work Monday-Wednesday.  And Sunday, I guess, is the day to sleep in and hide in my house. Hiding out is the one thing I feel like doing a lot of these days.  My food truck's ReOpening wasn't the only thing happening in my hometown this weekend past.  A 13-year-old boy was accidentally shot and killed on Saturday and then yesterday, the police department busted one of the biggest meth labs in a long time. Both are tragic...one is a sad loss, one that will devastate a loving family for the rest of their lives.  One is tragic only because of the profound stupidity/ignorance/addiction of a few people who happen to be living in a town mostly filled with good-hearted, hard-working people. And if it's not drama at the local level, then there's the constant bombardment of news that seems to be vividly...

We Overeat...Because We're Getting Fatter?

Well, if that just doesn't flip conventional medical wisdom on its head, I don't know what will. So I'm reading "Why We Get Fat" by Gary Taubes, right? Chapter 9 is titled "Laws of Adiposity" - much of the first section discusses an experiment conducted by George Wade.  After removing the ovaries from three sets of female lab rats, this is what he found: 1. The rats who were allowed to eat whatever, whenever gained weight and became obese. 2. The rats who were put on a strict post-surgery diet still gained weight and became obese. 3. The rats who were injected with estrogen and left to whatever eating pattern they chose did not grow obese. Obviously, this experiment (with further explanation in the book) linked the presence of estrogen to weight loss/gain.  Taubes goes on to say "estrogen influences an enzyme called lipoprotein lipase (LPL)".  These enzymes pull fat into cells that express a need for it (91).  When there is no estrog...

Fun With Tomato Juice

This blog entry has quite a backstory, but I'll sum it up quickly. In making the mega-batch of Red Sauce, I drained roughly 32 oz of juice from a large can of diced tomatoes.  "Waste not, want not", so I froze the leftover liquid, to be used at a later time. That time was today.  My original thought was to concoct a chili or similar, but then...I had ideas! Searching online, I found a recipe for Tomato-Basil soup at www.allrecipes.com.  With slight modifications (I had no crushed tomatoes or fresh basil) to the soup, today's lunch was soup and grilled cheese sandwiches.  Raves all around, and I guess now I can say goodbye to Campbell's Tomato Soup. Thank you - allrecipes.com! That left me with another 20 or so ounces of remaining tomato juice, and I was hankering to do something crazy with it.  And what would be on the other end of the tomato usage spectrum, if innocent, comforting tomato soup is on the another? The Bloody Mary, of course!  Blo...